0275 | A Town Like Alice – Nevil Shute

P1010205

Context: Finished this off on Trinity Beach just north of Cairns which is mentioned often in this novel.

REVIEW

A very, very long time ago, I was a teenage boy. At that time, I read Shute’s masterpiece, On the Beach, and loved it’s melancholy and dead-end conclusion. I was interested then in reading Alice and finding out how it compared and how I’d react to his writing after so long.

Well this is a wholly different book from On the Beach. For , a start, it’s a positive novel which focusses on the life of one main character, the remarkable Jean Paget. That Jean’s early experiences are based on a woman in real life is amazing too. Shute met someone who really had spent three years of the war walking non-stop from one Japanese officer to another… and not only survived but thrived. And Jean goes on from her war experiences to use an inheritance she receives with astonishing vision and acumen.

While I liked the character of Jean a lot, I found the framework that Shute used for the narration of the novel somewhat cumbersome. The novel is told by one of the trustees of her inheritance, an aged lawyer who takes a slightly more personal interest, shall we say, in Jean’s affairs as the novel goes on. What I found irritating about this was that when Jean was halfway around the world, he was narrating detailed conversations and feelings etc. This just didn’t work for me. It was far too forced. However, although the narrators perspective is warped in my opinion, it’s a device that works to convey the issues that arise from aging, loneliness and love and I did appreciate that.

The story basically falls into three parts. There’s Jean’s wartime experiences which could probably have been a novel itself. This then leads up to her heading off to Australia and the town like Alice that she attempts to build. There’s a final sub-plot towards the end which I wont spoil for you.

I wasn’t entirely sure what Shute’s purpose was in writing the novel. If it was to show the indefatigable spirit of a person, he has succeeded. But in order to do this, he links together three quite different extreme experiences. That someone would have three such experiences is, I found, a tad implausible. But, that aside, there is a story to catch your attention there and characters that make you care.

OPENING LINE

James Macfadden died in March 1905 when he was forty-seven years old; he was riding in the Driffield Point-to-Point.

CLOSING LINE

Of that girl that I met forty years too late, and of her life in that small town that I shall never see again, that holds so much of my affection.

RATING

alice

Key: Legacy | Plot / toPic | Characterisation / faCts | Readability | Achievement
Read more about how I come up with my ratings

  • Thomas at My Porch August 16, 2010, 7:33 pm

    I love Nevil Shute and I can totally understand your reservations about this book. I find him to have wonderful stories to tell but I would never call his writing genius. I enjoyed Alice, but I have liked other Shute titles much better.

    Reply
  • mum harris October 6, 2010, 12:29 pm

    A book I have actually read – loved all Nevil Shute!

    Reply
    • Arukiyomi October 9, 2010, 9:55 pm

      ah! Good! I know our literary paths don’t cross as often as I’d like so I’m pleased to hear that!

      Reply
  • sakura October 10, 2010, 8:09 pm

    I did it the other way round. I read A Town Like Alice as a teenager at school and only recently finished On the Beach. I recall liking the former although I can’t remember much of the detail except the general storyline, but I loved On the Beach. I haven’t read any other books by Shute but I’m planning to.

    Love the name of your blog – Arukiyomi. And I’m also impressed with your rating graph (is it a graph?)!

    Reply
    • Arukiyomi October 10, 2010, 10:47 pm

      thanks for the comment. Yes, it is a graph. I think it’s called a radar graph.

      Reply

Leave a Comment

%d bloggers like this: